Image 1 of 1
Image 1 of 1
Image 1 of 1
Image 1 of 1
Pickup: Oxford Farmers Market, Thursday 4–7 PM at the Churchlady Bakes booth.
Preorder note: This item is for market pickup only. Please choose the Oxford Farmers Market pickup option at checkout.
All orders must be picked up during the market window.
Some cookies whisper. This one walks into the fellowship hall and gets everybody talking.
Pastor’s Favorite Banana Pudding Cookie is our Southern banana pudding cookie made with a soft banana-vanilla dough, a creamy pudding-style center, and a golden vanilla wafer crumb coating that gives every bite that old-school dessert table flavor.
It’s nostalgic, creamy, sweet, and just sassy enough to make you understand why folks keep asking for it by name.
Soft banana-vanilla cookie with creamy pudding-style filling, golden wafer crumb coating, and classic banana pudding flavor in every bite.
Each cookie is approximately 4 oz.
Baked fresh in small batches. Best enjoyed within 3–4 days of pickup.
Store in an airtight container at room temperature. For best texture, enjoy fresh or warm slightly before serving.
Made fresh in small batches in Social Circle, Georgia.
Pickup: Oxford Farmers Market, Thursday 4–7 PM at the Churchlady Bakes booth.
Preorder note: This item is for market pickup only. Please choose the Oxford Farmers Market pickup option at checkout.
All orders must be picked up during the market window.
Some cookies whisper. This one walks into the fellowship hall and gets everybody talking.
Pastor’s Favorite Banana Pudding Cookie is our Southern banana pudding cookie made with a soft banana-vanilla dough, a creamy pudding-style center, and a golden vanilla wafer crumb coating that gives every bite that old-school dessert table flavor.
It’s nostalgic, creamy, sweet, and just sassy enough to make you understand why folks keep asking for it by name.
Soft banana-vanilla cookie with creamy pudding-style filling, golden wafer crumb coating, and classic banana pudding flavor in every bite.
Each cookie is approximately 4 oz.
Baked fresh in small batches. Best enjoyed within 3–4 days of pickup.
Store in an airtight container at room temperature. For best texture, enjoy fresh or warm slightly before serving.
Made fresh in small batches in Social Circle, Georgia.